Choosing the right siding is a big decision for homeowners looking to enhance their home’s curb appeal while protecting it from the elements.
Cedar siding and LP SmartSide are two of the most popular choices, each offering unique benefits. While cedar provides a natural, classic appearance, LP SmartSide offers engineered durability with a wood-like aesthetic. Understanding how they compare can help homeowners decide which material best fits their needs.
Cedar Siding vs. LP SmartSide: Key Differences Explained
Durability & Weather Resistance
Cedar siding is known for its natural resistance to moisture and insects, but it still requires regular upkeep to prevent rot, warping, and damage from pests like termites and woodpeckers. Even with proper maintenance, cedar can deteriorate over time, especially in areas with high humidity or extreme weather changes.
LP SmartSide is engineered with SmartGuard® technology, making it highly resistant to moisture, decay, and pests. It stands up well against harsh weather conditions, including heavy rain, snow, and temperature fluctuations. LP SmartSide products are designed to last up to 30 years, making them a long-term solution for homeowners who want durability without constant upkeep.
Maintenance Requirements & Lifespan
Cedar siding requires consistent maintenance, including sealing, staining, or painting every few years to protect it from moisture and sun damage. Over time, untreated cedar can fade to a grayish color, which some homeowners appreciate but others find undesirable.
LP SmartSide requires far less maintenance. It comes pre-primed and can be painted in a variety of colors, with the finish lasting much longer than traditional wood. With minimal upkeep, LP SmartSide retains its appearance and durability, offering homeowners peace of mind without the need for frequent refinishing.
Cost Breakdown: Initial Investment & Long-Term Savings
Cedar siding typically requires a higher upfront investment. The overall cost varies based on the grade and quality, with installation adding to the expense. In addition to the initial cost, ongoing maintenance—such as staining, painting, and repairs—contributes to long-term expenses.
LP SmartSide is generally a more budget-friendly option. Its materials are more affordable, and the installation process is quicker and easier, often resulting in lower labor costs. Homeowners also benefit from long-term savings since LP SmartSide requires less maintenance compared to cedar.
Aesthetic Appeal & Design Flexibility
Cedar siding has a distinctive, natural beauty that gives homes a warm, rustic charm. It comes in various styles, including shingles, clapboards, and shakes, offering flexibility in design. However, color options are limited to natural wood tones unless painted.
LP SmartSide mimics the look of real wood but offers more design options. It’s available in multiple textures and colors, allowing homeowners to customize their siding without worrying about fading or frequent touch-ups. Unlike cedar, which may warp or crack over time, LP SmartSide maintains its clean, uniform appearance for decades.
Environmental Impact & Sustainability
Cedar siding is a renewable resource, but harvesting wood for siding can contribute to deforestation if not sourced responsibly. While some cedar comes from sustainably managed forests, the availability and cost of eco-friendly options vary.
LP SmartSide is made from engineered wood that incorporates recycled materials and sustainable forestry practices. The production process creates less waste compared to natural wood siding, making it a better choice for homeowners prioritizing sustainability.
Choosing the Right Siding for Your Home
Best Option for Different Climates
Cedar siding performs well in moderate climates but can struggle in areas with extreme weather. High humidity, heavy rainfall, or extreme heat can lead to premature deterioration.
LP SmartSide is ideal for a variety of climates due to its engineered design. It resists moisture and withstands extreme temperatures, making it a better option for homeowners in regions with unpredictable weather patterns.
Installation, Warranty, and Long-Term Value
Cedar siding installation requires skilled craftsmanship, as improper installation can lead to gaps, warping, or moisture damage. It also lacks a comprehensive manufacturer’s warranty, with protection typically limited to specific grades of wood.
LP SmartSide is designed for easier installation, with longer boards that reduce seams and speed up the process. It also comes with a 50-year limited warranty, providing homeowners with long-term protection and peace of mind.
Expert Recommendations from C&T Siding & Windows
At C&T Siding & Windows, we help homeowners choose siding materials that fit their needs, budget, and long-term goals. While cedar has its charm, LP SmartSide offers superior durability, lower maintenance, and better value over time. For those looking for a siding solution that balances beauty with performance, LP SmartSide is often the better investment.
Final Thoughts: Which Siding Should You Choose?
Cedar siding and LP SmartSide each have their advantages, but LP SmartSide stands out for its durability, low maintenance, affordability, and sustainability. Homeowners who want a wood-like appearance without the drawbacks of traditional cedar will appreciate LP SmartSide’s benefits.
Looking for LP SmartSide solutions for your home but don’t know where to start? Get a free consultation with C&T Siding & Windows, and let us help you find the perfect siding solution.
